Cash on the Sidelines Myth and Tax-Efficient ETF Conversions | Ep 15

Watch or listen to the episode below:

The financial media loves big scary numbers. The latest obsession: $7 trillion sitting in "cash on the sidelines," supposedly waiting to flood into stocks and drive markets even higher.

Like most market talking points, this one falls apart under basic scrutiny.

The Context Everyone Ignores

$7 trillion sounds enormous until you remember the US stock market is worth over $60 trillion. That puts cash at about 12% of total market value, which is historically typical for both bull and bear markets.

Andy did the math live: $7 trillion divided by 350 million Americans equals roughly $20,000 per person. That includes kids who probably don't have twenty grand lying around, making the actual per-adult figure quite reasonable for emergency fund planning.

Why "Sidelines Cash" Doesn't Drive Markets

The "cash will chase returns" narrative misses how markets actually work. Most of that money flowing into stocks goes through index funds and 401(k) contributions. These are price takers, not price makers. They accept whatever price the market offers rather than determining what stocks should be worth.

The real price discovery happens through active managers, hedge funds, and institutional investors who actually analyze fair value. Your monthly 401(k) contribution doesn't move Apple's stock price. It just buys whatever shares are available at current levels.

The 2022 Reality Check

Remember the "cash is king" crowd from late 2022? When the Fed pushed money market rates to 5%, everyone proclaimed the death of stock investing. Why take equity risk when cash guaranteed 5%?

Those who followed that logic missed 20%+ stock market gains in 2023, another 20%+ in 2024, and 15%+ so far this year. Even the guaranteed 5% looks pretty weak against 50%+ cumulative equity returns over the same period.

The Fed has already started cutting rates, and money market yields are dropping in real time. Adam mentioned getting an email about cash account rates falling from 4% to 3.7% the day they recorded. That 5% "guaranteed" return is evaporating faster than Halloween candy.

The ETF Tax Revolution

The episode's second half tackled a more complex but potentially valuable topic: Section 351 conversions. This 100-year-old tax provision, originally designed to help people start businesses, now enables sophisticated ETF strategies.

Fund managers discovered they can use Section 351 to launch ETFs by accepting existing stock portfolios from investors without triggering capital gains taxes. You contribute your individual stocks, get ETF shares back, and defer all tax consequences until you actually sell the ETF.

Why ETF Structure Matters

ETFs offer remarkable tax efficiency for active strategies. In a regular brokerage account, selling Apple to buy Exxon triggers immediate capital gains taxes. Inside an ETF, managers can essentially swap securities without creating taxable events for shareholders.

This happens through the ETF's unique creation and redemption process. When the manager wants to trade Apple for Exxon, they can often structure the transaction to avoid triggering capital gains for the fund. Shareholders only face taxes when they sell their ETF shares.

The Diversification Requirements

Section 351 conversions aren't available for concentrated positions. The tax code requires no single position exceed 25% of contributed assets, and the top five positions can't exceed 50% combined. This ensures you're contributing a diversified portfolio to receive diversified ETF shares.

Asset Location Beats Asset Allocation

The episode concluded with listener feedback about charitable remainder trusts, highlighting why asset location often matters more than asset allocation. One listener had two CRTs with identical 5% payout rates but dramatically different account values after several years.

The difference likely came down to investment selection within each trust. CRTs have specific tax consequences based on what types of income they generate. Distributions come out in a specific order: ordinary income first, then capital gains, then tax-free municipal income, finally return of principal.

Smart CRT investing focuses on long-term capital gains and tax-free municipal bonds to minimize the ordinary income that gets distributed first. Many investors treat their CRT like any other account, missing the tax optimization opportunities that make these vehicles worthwhile.

Beyond the Numbers

Whether it's cash flow analysis or tax-efficient fund structures, the lesson remains consistent: context matters more than headlines. $7 trillion sounds scary until you see it represents normal cash allocation patterns. Complex tax strategies make sense for some situations but require understanding the details, not just the marketing pitch.

The markets will continue finding reasons to go up or down regardless of how much cash sits in money market funds. Focus on long-term planning rather than trying to predict when sideline cash will finally "rotate" into risk assets.

Listen to the full conversation on Long Story Short: